Secured vs Unsecured Personal Loans: What Is the Difference?
Secured vs unsecured personal loans is a distinction based on whether the loan is backed by collateral: a secured personal loan pledges an asset the lender can take if you default, while an unsecured personal loan relies only on your promise and credit history. That single difference shapes the interest rate, the approval odds, and the risk a borrower carries.
The lowest rates are only available to the most qualified applicants. We may be paid a commission if you apply through this link.
The Core Difference: Collateral
A secured personal loan requires the borrower to pledge an asset, which gives the lender a second way to recover its money if payments stop. Common forms of collateral include a savings account, a certificate of deposit, a vehicle, or an investment account. Because the lender can seize the asset, it takes on less risk, and that usually translates into a lower interest rate or a higher chance of approval for a borrower with imperfect credit.
An unsecured personal loan has no collateral. The lender evaluates credit history, income, and existing debt, and it relies on the borrower's willingness and ability to repay. If the borrower defaults, the lender's main remedies are collection efforts and, potentially, a lawsuit, rather than taking a specific asset.
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau describes how a personal installment loan is repaid in fixed payments over a set term, and both secured and unsecured personal loans typically follow that structure.
How Rates and Approval Differ
Because collateral reduces the lender's risk, secured loans generally price lower than unsecured loans for the same borrower. The size of the advantage depends on the asset and the borrower's credit. A cash deposit pledged as security is the most attractive to a lender because its value is stable, while a vehicle that depreciates offers less comfort.
Approval also tends to be easier with security. A borrower with a thin or damaged credit file may qualify for a secured loan when an unsecured application would be declined, because the lender's exposure is smaller. The trade-off is that the borrower has put something at risk, so the lower rate is not free.
For unsecured loans, the credit profile drives everything. Borrowers with strong credit may receive rates competitive with secured products, while those with weaker credit may face much higher rates or be declined. Comparing the annual percentage rate across offers is the practical way to see the real gap, because the APR includes fees that the interest rate leaves out. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau explains that difference.
Side-by-Side Comparison
The table below summarizes how the two loan types compare across the factors that matter most to a borrower.
| Factor | Secured personal loan | Unsecured personal loan |
|---|---|---|
| Collateral | Required | None |
| Typical rate | Generally lower | Generally higher |
| Approval difficulty | Easier with weaker credit | Harder with weaker credit |
| Risk to borrower | Pledged asset can be taken | No specific asset at risk |
| Borrowing limit | Tied to the asset's value | Tied to income and credit |
| Funding speed | May take longer to value the asset | Often faster |
Neither option is universally better. A borrower with strong credit and no asset to spare may find an unsecured loan simpler and nearly as cheap, while a borrower with a blemished file and a spare savings balance may prefer the secured route.
When a Secured Personal Loan Makes Sense
A secured loan can be a sound choice when the borrower wants a lower rate, needs to qualify despite weak credit, or is using the loan to build credit. A deposit-secured loan, where the borrower pledges funds held by the lender, is a common example: the payment history can be reported to credit bureaus, and the lender's risk is minimal because it already holds the security.
It can also make sense when the pledged asset is not needed during the loan term. Pledging a certificate of deposit that is not part of an emergency fund, for instance, may cost little in practical terms while reducing the borrowing cost. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau notes that installment loans can carry fees, so those should be weighed against the rate savings.
The decision changes when the collateral is something the borrower relies on. Pledging a car that is needed for work, or a home, puts an essential asset on the line. In those cases the lower rate may not justify the risk, and an unsecured loan or a smaller borrowing amount may be the safer path.
The Risk of Losing Pledged Property
The most important difference for many borrowers is what happens on default. With a secured loan, the lender can take the pledged asset, sell it, and apply the proceeds to the debt. If the sale brings less than the balance owed, the borrower may still be responsible for the remainder, depending on the agreement and state law.
That means a secured loan can turn a financial setback into the loss of property. A home equity loan or line of credit, for example, is secured by the home, and the Federal Trade Commission warns that failing to repay can lead to foreclosure. Borrowers considering home-secured lending should treat the risk as seriously as they would the risk to any essential asset.
Unsecured loans carry their own consequences. Default can lead to collection calls, negative credit reporting, and eventually a lawsuit, but it does not directly cost the borrower a specific piece of property. The bad credit loan cost calculator can help a borrower see how much a weaker credit profile adds to the cost of an unsecured loan.
The value of the collateral also matters over time. A vehicle loses value as it ages, which can leave the borrower owing more than the asset is worth if the loan term is long. A deposit account, by contrast, holds a steady value and gives the lender little reason to worry. Matching the loan term to the type of collateral reduces the chance of a shortfall.
How to Choose Between the Two
Choosing starts with an honest inventory. List the assets available to pledge and decide which, if any, could be lost without disrupting your life. Then compare the rates and APRs of a secured offer and an unsecured offer for the same amount and term, using a personal loan calculator to see how each affects the monthly payment and the total cost.
Consider how long the money is needed. A short-term need may not justify pledging an asset, while a longer term magnifies the benefit of a lower rate. Also weigh how the loan will be repaid if income falls; a secured loan converts a payment problem into a property problem faster than an unsecured loan does.
Finally, read the agreement carefully before signing, paying attention to what is pledged, the default triggers, and whether prepayment is allowed. The guide to choosing a secured or unsecured loan walks through the decision in more detail, and the guide to unsecured loan debt covers how unsecured obligations behave if they go unpaid.
It also helps to ask how the loan will be reported and whether the payments will appear on credit reports, because a secured loan used to build credit only helps if the activity is reported. Confirming that detail before applying prevents a borrower from expecting a credit benefit that never arrives.
Frequently asked questions
Are secured personal loans always cheaper?
They usually carry lower rates because the lender has collateral, but not always. Fees, the loan term, and the borrower's credit can narrow or reverse the gap, so comparing APRs is the reliable approach.
What can I use as collateral for a personal loan?
Common forms include savings accounts, certificates of deposit, vehicles, and investment accounts. Lenders prefer assets that are easy to value and sell, and the loan amount is usually a percentage of that value.
Does a secured loan hurt my credit if I default?
Default can be reported to credit bureaus and damage your score, and the lender may also seize the pledged asset. The credit impact and the loss of property are separate consequences that can both occur.
Can I get an unsecured loan with bad credit?
It is possible, but the rates tend to be high and approval is not guaranteed. A co-signer, a smaller amount, or a secured loan may offer better terms for a borrower with a weak credit file.
Is a home equity loan the same as a secured personal loan?
A home equity loan is a type of secured loan because the home backs it, but it is a mortgage product with its own rules and risks. Putting a home at risk is a serious step that deserves careful consideration.
- What is a personal installment loan? — Consumer Financial Protection Bureau
- Do personal installment loans have fees? — Consumer Financial Protection Bureau
- Home equity loans and home equity lines of credit — Federal Trade Commission
- What is the difference between a loan interest rate and the APR? — Consumer Financial Protection Bureau
Check your rate with a lending partner in about two minutes. Checking does not affect your credit score.
Check your rateThe lowest rates are only available to the most qualified applicants. We may be paid a commission if you apply through this link. This does not affect our calculators or guides, which are free and independent.